Discussion about this post

User's avatar
pete gee's avatar

A TRUE AND FAIR ANALYSIS

Raj's avatar

It is great to see someone manage to elucidate criticism for both sides. I think it would be useful to draw up exactly what humanists should be supporting, because it is definitely not either US imperialism or religious dictatorship. A US abject loss would limit imperialist attrocities elsewhere, and arguably could slow the decline in US democracy by undermining imperialist ambitions, but would do nothing for the suffering of the Iranian people.

The best case for the Iranian people is that the US engages meaningfully with reformists in or potentially in government, providing a pathway to stepwise gradual normalisation of relations as moves towards democracy and reduction of corruption take place. Coincidentally that would also be in the best of interests of ... pretty much everyone, apart from the current US and Iranian regimes. This does seem unthinkable at the moment, but taking a step back it is the only reasonable solution.

9 more comments...

No posts

Ready for more?